2nd String Hall of Fame

votefavorite1This is going to be a year-long popularity/beauty contest/tournment in which Fanatical readers will vote for their favorite SECOND (and third) STRING COMIC BOOK CHARACTERS. Frankly, I’m not sure exactly how this is going to work, except that I’m going to come up with a bunch of nominees and I’ll also take suggestions from fanatical readers. Five new characters each month for nine months. Then there will be some kind of playoffs so that at the end of 2009, there will be official FUNNY BOOK FANATIC 2ND STRING HALL OF FAME INDUCTEES.


Round Two Winner: SPEEDBALL


Round One Winner: ZATANNA












Round Three Winner: Doctor Fate

Round Three Winner: DOCTOR FATE

Here are the winners for the first three rounds: Zatanna, Speedball, and Dr. Fate.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * 

Here is the ALL-FEMALE nominees for ROUND FOUR of our contest. VOTE IN THE BOX ABOVE!!!

Big Barda

Big Barda



Big Barda (DC Hero)

Big Barda was a BBW (big, beautiful woman) before the term was popularized in magazines and television. Her first appearance was in Mister Miracle #4 and was part of the NEW GODS mythology that Jack Kirby created at DC Comics. Big Barda was created as a female companion to Scott Free alias Mr. Miracle. According to Mark Evanier, who worked as Kirby’s assistant for a time, the interplay between the two characters was patterned in part on Jack and Roz Kirby’s relationship. Born on Apokolips and raised by Granny Goodness, Barda was supposed to be one of the bad guys. Since falling in love with Mr. Miracle and becoming a hero, Barda has had a long association with the Justice League and a more recent one with Oracle and The Birds of Prey. Plus, how can you resist a girl who has this description from Wikipedia, “She wields a high tech weapon called a Mega-rod, which produces extremely powerful concussive bursts.” ’nuff said.



Lorna Dane / Polaris

Lorna Dane/Polaris (Marvel hero)

Hard to believe that any character that has been connected to the X-Men franchise as long as Lorna Dane still gets so little respect and so little exposure that she can be considered for this balloting. Created by writer Arnold Drake and artist Jim Steranko for X-Men #49, Lorna is the mistress of magnetism, Magneto’s daughter, half-sister to Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch, the fiance (or ex-fiance) of Cyclop’s brother Havok. She’s the only character who springs to mind who has suffered from more bad costumes than Janet Van Dyne (The Wasp). In her long and twisted history, poor Lorna has been unable to sort out here relationship with Alex Summers (Havok) and her writers have altered her powers, took away her powers, gave her different powers, gave her pseudo-artificial powers and then took away her powers again. Poor Lorna. Her green hair is in no way related to gamma rays, at least not in any story so far.


Savage She-Dragon

Savage She-Dragon




Savage She-Dragon (Image hero)

Even though she started her “life” as a villain named Sensation, Amy Belcher eventually became known as The Savage She-Dragon. She has been a regular player in Erik Larsen’s long running Image title, The Savage Dragon. After her long blonde tresses were burned off by the Dragon-Slayer, she grew a mohawk which she sports to this day. Originally a parody of She-Hulk inside a larger parody of the work of John Byrne, she proved to be popular enough that when Savage Dragon was thought to have died in issue #50, the title was retitled The Savage She-Dragon for issues #51 through #54.





Marvel's Thundra




Thundra (Marvel Hero/Villain)

Thundra, like previous nominee Big Barda, is a warrior woman from another world. In this case, the stunning redhead in the red costume came to Marvel’s Earth from the 23rd Century. In Thundra’s future, women have taken control of the planet by enslaving the male portion of the population. Every time there are societal movements, there are characters that refect the movement. No character is a better mix of the admiration and paranoia that was all mixed up in the women’s liberation movement than Thundra. She’s been associated with The Fantastic Four (including a love/hate relationship with Ben Grimm), The Frightful Four, Project Pegasus, The Inhumans, The Avengers and most recently Jeph Loeb featured Thundra along with some other Marvel female heroes in the pages of The Hulk. She’s big, she’s strong, she’s confident, she’s sexy and she’s a warrior from another time. What’s not to like?


DC's Vixen

DC's Vixen




Vixen (DC Hero)

Created by the great Gerry Conway and artist Bob Oksner, according the Wikipedia, Vixen was very nearly the first black female DC superhero to star in her own series. The first issue was produced, but was then caught 1978’s “DC Implosion.” Eventually, Vixen made her first official appearance in Action Comics #521. Mari Jiwe McCabe was raised in Africa, but moved to New York City to be a model.

Upon a return trip to Africa, she gains possession of a fox-shaped totem that was part of her family’s heritage. The totem gives Mari the power to call on the powers of the animal world (and her powers may have the same source as Animal Man’s). Vixen was part of the Justice League of America when Aquaman re-organized the team and she departed when Martian Manhunter later disbanded this version of the team. She’s spent time fighting side-by-side with Animal Man, the Suicide Squad and Oracle’s Birds of Prey. In 2008, Vixen even got her own 5-issue limited series in which writer G. Willow Wilson told an adventure of Mari’s return to Africa. And just for the record, Vixen is included in this round of nominees based on a suggestion from a fanatical reader.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * 

First round (non-winning nominees)


Second round (non-winning nominees)


Third round (non-winning nominees)



16 responses to “2nd String Hall of Fame

  1. Dave Olbrich

    I’m hereby nominating Marvel’s RED WOLF and DC’s RAGMAN.

  2. I nominate Marvel’s Speedball and DC’s Mary Marvel.

  3. I nominate Whirlwind, Stiltman, Melter, Gladiator, Beetle, Living Laser, Super Adaptoid, & Trapster.

  4. Come on, Dave. Wildcat has NEVER been second string…..

    Your amgio,


  5. Dave Olbrich

    Don’t misunderstand Beau, I think Wildcat is great, but he’s not exactly Iron Man or Green Lantern level. At this point, I think I’d consider Luke Cage 2nd string. Maybe even Blue Beetle, definitely Blue Devil. Where do we draw the line?

  6. I nominate Damage (DC) as the character with the most convoluted backstory ever (even moreso than Jocasta (Marvel) or Hawkman (DC)).

    Other nominees for X-stringers would be the Mimic (Marvel), Slapstick (Marvel), and Bouncing Boy (DC), even though the last one was “the Greatest Legionnaire of All” (a great Neal Adams cover to an Adventure Comics issue late in their run).

    Then again, depending on your views of the Legion of Super-Heroes, are all of them 2nd-stringers or not? I’ve loved them since I started reading comics in 1974 (though I stopped reading their books fully when they went too dark for my tastes in 2000). Great characters, but again (as above), where do you draw the line? Is Timber Wolf now perceived as a Wolverine clone even though he predates Logan by a good decade or more?

    Interesting. I’d love to see a long blog re: what constitutes the second/third string?

    Steven Schend
    an old TSR contact from long ago

  7. Dave Olbrich

    Steven —
    What a great surprise to see you here.

    Do you think a long detailed blog in an attempt to define second string heroes would be good … or mind-numbingly boring?

    For now, I’m going to stick with my reasonably flexible and not-all-fair vague definition, unless there is a ground swell of support for a serious hard core definition.

  8. Pingback: Malibu Comics Secret Origins (part two) « Funny Book Fanatic

  9. Pingback: Blog of the Month, more 2nd String Hall of Fame Nominees « Funny Book Fanatic

  10. snowbag

    I can’t bring myself to think of Fate as second-string. He was too central to the revival of the Golden Age characters.

  11. Paul O'Connor

    I voted for Fate, but I agree — he might be a B-lister, but not a second-stringer. He’s slumming when with the likes of Stingray.

    Too early to start nominating for the next round? What happens when you’re sidekick to a second-stringer? Ask … Devil Dinosaur’s MOON BOY!!!

  12. Dave Olbrich

    Yeah, Fate and Stingray in the same category is sort of hard to take, but I decided long ago to avoid splitting too many hairs in this decidedly unfair contest.

    And what kind of hair is O’Connor splitting when he makes a distinction between B-lister and 2nd string?

  13. Paul O'Connor

    B-listers get their own book every once in awhile, and not just some desultory min-series to maintain copyright. They still get headlines, but they aren’t stars. In the movies, they’re Jeff Goldblum. Gary Oldman.

    2nd-stringers never get their own books. They’re like character actors or second bananas on a TV show. Movies: Lance Henricksen. John Rhys-Davies.

  14. Pingback: DR. FATE is the 2nd String (third round) winner « Funny Book Fanatic

  15. Pingback: Brevoort, Anderson, Marder and other FANATIC name dropping « Funny Book Fanatic

  16. Ola

    “I think I’d consider Luke Cage 2nd string”. Shameful statement! Power Man and Iron Fist was a decent series, and Cage has a lot more back story, depth and canon than the heroes you are ranking him with.

    Good site tho.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s